Publication Guidelines

The TMJM is committed to maintaining high standards of academic excellence, scholarly quality, transparency, and integrity in the publication of research and scholarly works. The following policies govern the submission, evaluation, review, and publication of manuscripts.

1. Peer Review Requirement and Process

The TMJM shall not accept or publish any manuscript without prior peer review, except for editorial materials or other content categories expressly exempted from external peer review under the journal's editorial guidelines.

Every manuscript submitted for publication shall undergo evaluation by at least one qualified internal or external reviewer with appropriate expertise in the subject area or discipline covered by the manuscript. Manuscripts that are clearly unsuitable for consideration because of serious deficiencies in scope, content, quality, or presentation may be rejected by the Editor-in-Chief without proceeding to external peer review.

Manuscripts that meet the journal's initial screening requirements shall be forwarded to qualified reviewers for substantive evaluation. Reviewers are expected to complete their assessment and submit their recommendations within two (2) months from receipt of the manuscript.

The TMJM shall adopt a double-blind peer review process, whereby the identities of both the authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.

2. Role of Editorial Board Members in the Peer Review Process

An editorial board member with relevant expertise in the subject area of a submitted manuscript may conduct a preliminary assessment or serve as a reviewer, provided that no actual or potential conflict of interest exists.

If the editorial board member finds the manuscript unsuitable for publication, he or she may recommend to the Editor-in-Chief its rejection without further review. If the manuscript is considered potentially suitable for publication, the editorial board member may recommend its acceptance or refer it to another qualified expert for further evaluation.

Editorial board members who are authors or co-authors of a submitted manuscript, have a personal or professional relationship with the authors, or otherwise have a conflict of interest shall not participate in the review or editorial decision-making process for that manuscript.

All editorial recommendations shall be submitted to the Editor-in-Chief, who shall retain ultimate authority and responsibility for the final publication decision.

3. Timeliness of Editorial Evaluation and Publication

The TMJM shall endeavor to process, evaluate, and communicate decisions on submitted manuscripts as promptly and efficiently as possible without compromising the quality and integrity of the peer review process.

Manuscripts that successfully pass the peer review and editorial evaluation processes shall be prepared for publication at the earliest possible opportunity, subject to the journal's publication schedule, technical requirements, and applicable editorial standards.

The journal shall make reasonable efforts to inform authors of the status of their submissions and any anticipated delays in the review or publication process.

4. Quality, Clarity, and Scholarly Standards of Manuscripts

Authors are expected to ensure that their manuscripts are written with clarity, coherence, accuracy, and precision. Submissions must demonstrate scholarly rigor and be adequately supported by appropriate research methods, evidence, analyses, references, and proofs, where applicable.

Manuscripts must make a meaningful contribution to their respective fields of study and must conform to the journal's prescribed formatting, referencing, and submission requirements.

Manuscripts that are poorly written, inadequately substantiated, methodologically unsound, or unclear in their presentation may be returned to the authors for improvement or rejected.

5. Editorial Decisions and Responsibilities of the Editor-in-Chief

The Editor-in-Chief shall carefully evaluate the reviewers' comments and recommendations and shall notify the corresponding author of the editorial decision regarding the manuscript.

The ultimate responsibility for accepting or rejecting a manuscript rests with the Editor-in-Chief. In making this decision, the Editor-in-Chief shall consider the reviewers' recommendations, the scholarly quality and relevance of the manuscript, its originality, methodological soundness, ethical compliance, and conformity with the journal's editorial standards.

The possible editorial decisions are as follows:

  • Accepted for Publication without Revisions – The manuscript is accepted in its present form.
  • Accepted Subject to Minor Revisions – The manuscript is accepted provided that the authors address minor editorial, technical, or substantive concerns. Further peer review shall generally not be required unless deemed necessary by the Editor-in-Chief.
  • Revise and Resubmit (Major Revisions) – The manuscript requires substantial revisions and may be subjected to further peer review before a final editorial decision is made.
  • Rejected – The manuscript is not considered suitable for publication in the TMJM because it does not meet the journal's academic, scholarly, or editorial standards.

Editorial decisions shall be based on the scholarly merit of the manuscript and shall be free from discrimination based on the authors' institutional affiliation, nationality, gender, religion, political beliefs, or other personal characteristics.

6. Communication and Revision of Manuscripts

The comments and recommendations of the anonymous reviewer(s), together with the editorial decision, shall be communicated to the corresponding author.

When revisions are required, the authors shall submit the revised manuscript within two (2) weeks from receipt of the reviewers' comments and the editorial decision, unless an extension is granted by the Editor-in-Chief.

Authors shall submit a revised manuscript accompanied by a point-by-point response explaining how each comment or recommendation of the reviewer(s) has been addressed. If an author disagrees with a particular recommendation, a clear and academically justified explanation shall be provided.

The TMJM shall allow a maximum of two (2) rounds of revision for each manuscript, unless exceptional circumstances warrant otherwise and the Editor-in-Chief grants an extension or additional revision opportunity.

Failure to submit the revised manuscript within the prescribed period, without an approved extension, may constitute grounds for withdrawal or rejection of the submission.

7. Originality, Exclusivity, and Duplicate Publication

The TMJM shall only consider manuscripts that constitute original scholarly work and have not been previously published or accepted for publication in another journal or publication venue.

Authors must certify that their manuscripts are not simultaneously under consideration for publication by another journal. Any prior publication, substantial overlap with previously published work, or related submission must be fully disclosed to the Editor-in-Chief at the time of submission.

The submission of substantially similar manuscripts to multiple journals, duplicate publication, and redundant publication without proper disclosure are prohibited.

Proper acknowledgment and citation must be given to all previously published works, materials, data, and ideas used in the manuscript.