AI Policies

The increasing use of Generative Artificial Intelligence (GAI) and other AI-assisted technologies is reshaping the landscape of academic research and scholarly publishing. TMJM recognizes the potential of these tools to support researchers in improving the efficiency, clarity, and presentation of their scholarly work. However, their use must be guided by clear ethical standards to ensure that AI technologies complement, rather than replace, human intellectual engagement, critical thinking, and original scholarly contributions.

In this regard, TMJM adopts the following policies to promote the responsible, transparent, and ethical use of AI tools in research and scholarly publishing.

1. General Policy

TMJM adheres to the MSU–Iligan Institute of Technology Ethical Use of AI Policy, which upholds the principles of transparency, accountability, academic integrity, and the ethical use of Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies.

Consistent with these principles, the TMJM recognizes that AI tools may serve as supplementary aids in scholarly work but must not undermine the originality, intellectual independence, and academic responsibility of authors. The use of such tools does not exempt authors from accountability for the accuracy, integrity, and authenticity of their submissions.

2. Use of AI Tools by Authors

Authors may use AI tools in limited and clearly defined capacities, provided that such use does not compromise the originality, intellectual substance, and integrity of their work. The following guidelines shall apply:

  • Language Editing and Refinement. Authors may use AI tools to improve grammar, spelling, punctuation, sentence structure, and language clarity. These tools may also be used to assist in organizing ideas and improving the coherence and readability of the manuscript, provided that the intellectual content remains the authors' own.
  • Originality of Scholarly Content. The use of AI tools to generate or develop the core intellectual content of a manuscript is prohibited. The formulation of research arguments, critical analyses, interpretations, and conclusions must be grounded in the authors' own knowledge, reasoning, and scholarly judgment.
  • Generation of Substantive Manuscript Content. Authors are not permitted to use AI tools to generate substantive portions of their manuscripts, including the abstract, literature review, research methodology, presentation and analysis of results, discussion, and conclusions. These sections must reflect the authors' original scholarly work and intellectual contributions.
  • Data Analysis and Research Integrity. AI tools may be used as supplementary aids in processing or analyzing data obtained through legitimate research methods. However, their use to fabricate, manipulate, simulate, or generate research data or findings presented as actual research results is strictly prohibited. Authors remain fully responsible for verifying the accuracy of AI-assisted analyses and for all interpretations and conclusions drawn from their research.
  • Visual Materials and Data Presentation. AI-generated images, illustrations, graphs, figures, and tables intended for presentation as research outputs are not permitted. All visual and tabular materials must be produced using appropriate and verifiable methods or obtained from legitimate sources with proper acknowledgment and attribution.
  • Disclosure of AI Use. Authors must disclose any use of AI tools in the preparation of their manuscripts. The disclosure must identify the AI tool or application used and clearly describe the purpose and extent of its use. This statement must be placed in a separate section entitled Declaration of AI Tool Use, immediately after the References section. If no AI tools were used, authors are encouraged to indicate this accordingly.

Disclosure of AI use does not automatically guarantee acceptance of a manuscript. The Journal reserves the right to evaluate whether the declared use of AI tools is consistent with its policies and ethical standards.

3. Use of AI Tools in the Editorial and Peer Review Process

TMJM is committed to maintaining a rigorous, impartial, and ethical editorial and peer review process. All editorial and review activities must uphold the principles of academic integrity, confidentiality, transparency, originality, and scholarly rigor.

To protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and the integrity of the review process, reviewers and editors are prohibited from using AI tools to generate, formulate, or substantially develop their evaluations, recommendations, and editorial decisions. However, limited use of AI-assisted tools is permitted for the following purposes:

  • Reference Verification. To assist in checking the authenticity, accuracy, and verifiability of references and other sources cited in the manuscript. All verification must be independently confirmed using reliable sources.
  • Plagiarism Detection. To assist in identifying potential instances of plagiarism, subject to verification through appropriate plagiarism-detection procedures and human assessment.
  • Language Refinement. To improve the grammar, sentence structure, and clarity of written feedback, provided that the substance, critical assessment, and recommendations remain entirely the work of the reviewer or editor.

Submitted manuscripts and all materials associated with the editorial and peer review process are strictly confidential. Reviewers and editors must not upload, share, or otherwise disclose manuscript contents, reviewer reports, or related confidential materials to publicly accessible or third-party AI platforms. Such practices may compromise manuscript confidentiality, intellectual property rights, copyright protection, and data privacy.

Reviewers and editors remain fully accountable for the content, accuracy, fairness, and integrity of their evaluations and editorial decisions, regardless of whether permitted AI-assisted tools are used.

4. Compliance with Ethical Standards

All submitted manuscripts shall undergo an initial screening to determine compliance with the ethical standards and publication policies of TMJM, including the appropriate and transparent use of AI tools.

Authors may be required to provide clarification or additional information regarding their declared use of AI tools when necessary. Manuscripts found to have violated the Journal's AI usage policies, including failure to disclose AI use where required, may be returned to the authors for clarification or revision, or rejected when the violation is deemed serious.

The Journal reserves the right to conduct further assessments and take appropriate action in cases involving suspected misuse of AI tools, fabrication or falsification of research content, or other violations of academic and publication ethics.

Ultimately, TMJM upholds the principle that AI technologies must remain supportive instruments in scholarly research and publishing. Original thinking, critical inquiry, intellectual responsibility, and academic integrity must remain at the core of all scholarly contributions.